I can't believe we met like this
   Is it just coincidence
   I had a feeling I'd be seeing you again
   Your every bit as beautiful as the last time we met
   When you told me, you were leaving, and going back to him
   How I wish that I could tell you, it's all in the past
   But I was never good at lying, and baby since you asked
  
   I don't want to hear that song again from the night we first met
   I don't want to hear you whispering, things I'd rather forget
   I don't want to look into your eyes, cause you know what happens next
   We'll be making love and then
   I fall all over again.
  
   I can't begin to tell you, just how sorry I am
   that the man you built your dreams around, just broke your heart again
   I think I know the feeling
   cause I once loved you so much
   that I swore I'd rather die than live a day without your touch
   If I held you in my arms you know, I'd never let you go
   But this ain't the time or place to get emotional
  
   I don't want to hear that song again, from the night we first met
   I don't want to hear you whispering, things I'd rather forget
   I don't want to look into your eyes, cause you know what happens next
   We'll be making love and then
   I'd fall all over again
  
   I was crying when you kissed me
   Then you walked out that door,
   Ohhh
   You were always such a mystery
   I still dream we're making love
   Then I stop myself because
  
   I don't want to hear that song again, from the night we first met
   I don't want to hear you whispering, things I'd rather forget
   I don't want to look into your eyes, cause you know what happens next
   We'll be making love and then
   I'd fall all over again
  
   I fall all over again